
The restaurant industry has seen a significant shift in power towards major brands and large franchise operators, which may be leaving small franchisees behind. Franchising has traditionally offered operators the benefits of entrepreneurship with reduced risks under a national brand. However, experts say this value proposition is now under threat.
Typically, franchised businesses have a higher survival rate than independent ones, with operators benefiting from established procedures, brand recognition, and marketing, according to Kristy Hall, senior vice president of specialty franchise lending at Bank of America. But small operators face challenges such as expensive development and reduced autonomy due to technology.
Challenges for Small Operators
About 19% of franchisees operate 60% of all units, Hall said, reflecting a gradual shift towards consolidation. The top three fastest-growing chains – Cinnabon, Dunkin’, and Chick-fil-A – accounted for 41% of net unit growth in 2025. Meanwhile, Subway, the country’s largest brand by unit count, lost over 729 units in a single year.
The concentration of strong performance in a handful of brands and operators raises concerns about franchising’s role in the American economy. Ulrich Atz, an assistant professor of accounting at Bocconi University, said franchise contracts have become more restrictive, limiting the autonomy and independence of small business owners.
Franchise Contracts Become Restrictive
Brian Callaci, an economist and campaign director with the Strategic Organizing Center, said brands now have the degree of insight into daily operations necessary to translate increased contractual control into an operational reality. This power over operations comes at a moment when consumers and workers are likely to see a franchisee as part of a brand rather than an independent entity.
Franchisor Control and Technology
Technology has progressed beyond simple point-of-sale monitoring, with chains like Burger King deploying an OpenAI voice assistant to monitor drive-thru interactions and offer coaching to workers. Pizza Hut’s Dragontail AI system, which manages order flows, has resulted in longer ticket times for some operators and shifted control over ordering channels from franchisees to franchisors.
Mark Wasilefsky, head of TD Bank’s restaurant franchise finance group, said technology can offer new ordering channels and ways for operators to collect customer data and refine offers. However, the major beneficiaries of recent structural changes in the restaurant industry are not individual operators, but rather large, well-capitalized franchisees with store operations ranging from a few dozen to thousands of units across different brands.
Kristy Hall said that the ideal franchisee is no longer necessarily someone with deep restaurant industry expertise, but rather someone with leadership skills and understanding of financial management. The emergence of a new class of large franchisees, known as MUMBOs (multi-unit multi-brand ownership), has changed the industry’s structure.
Large Franchisees Gain Advantage
John Gordon, founder and principal of Pacific Management Consulting Group, said that larger franchisees tend to have easier access to lending, which means higher interest rates have disproportionately impacted small operators. The quality of real estate has become more challenging for restaurant brands, with new construction being expensive and development timelines being longer.
Sun Holdings operates over 1,000 total restaurants, including over 200 Arby’s locations, a similar number of Papa John’s units, and 100 stores each of Burger King, Applebee’s, and Popeyes, according to its website. This scale of operation is becoming increasingly common, with large franchisees posing a problem for franchisors by disrupting the assertion of control that makes one- and two-store operators less independent.
Lenders now see the restaurant industry divided into three tiers, with operators of strong brands in the “A tier” having little trouble accessing capital, while brands that are doing okay but not well are classed as “B tier” debtors, and struggling chains like Jack in the Box and Pizza Hut are classed as “C tier” debtors, according to Gordon. The problem is that operators in the “C tier” can only access capital at exorbitant interest rates, making it even harder for them to survive.
Small Operators Face Survival Challenges
The failure of a single large franchisee can result in major problems for a chain, as bankruptcy proceedings can lead to disputes over control and lengthy processes to shift ailing units under new ownership. The simultaneous erosion of franchisee control and the strength of the jumbo MUMBOs reflect a market where virtually everything has gotten more difficult for small operators, with Gordon saying that there is no doubt that franchisees almost everywhere are weaker.
The last “good year” that restaurant franchisees had was probably 2022, according to Gordon, since then, increases in the costs of borrowing, coupled with greater price sensitivity among consumers and falling traffic, have all hurt franchisees. The impacts have been unevenly distributed, with larger franchisees tend to have easier access to lending, and the gap between high performers and low performers will only get worse.
In this challenging environment, small franchisees will need to find ways to adapt and survive, or risk being left behind by the larger, more powerful MUMBOs. With the rise of technology and the increasing control of franchisors, it is likely that the traditional model of franchising will continue to evolve, with smaller franchisees facing significant challenges in the years to come. The cost of development is $1.5 million per store, according to Gordon.




